Thinking Like Paul Krugman: Is Wine Passé?

I was re-reading an article titled “Is Free Trade Passé?” that the economist Paul Krugman wrote back in 1987 and it got me thinking about what’s happening in the world today. Here is my report.

>>><<<

Is Free Trade Passé? It is not so much the (very interesting) details of Krugman’s technical argument about free trade that caught my attention, but the basic nature of his conclusion.

A Rule of Thumb

Once upon a time, he writes, the benefits of  free trade were something that just about everyone in the economics profession agreed on. (The only thing, in fact, according to some.) But, as international trade theory advanced, the automatic advantages of free trade came into question and strong but narrow theories of not free trade emerged.

Does this mean that free trade is passé, Krugman asks? No, it is still a good rule of thumb just because there are so many ways that not free trade can go wrong. But it isn’t what it used to be.

This reminds me of the situation we find in wine today, although the resemblence is far from perfect.

Far from Default

Is wine passé? You know, over the hill? Once upon a time the pleasures and benefits of wine were broadly understood and appreciated. You might prefer beer or spirits to wine, but wine held its own. Wine, shared with others and consumed in moderation,  especially with food, was part of healthy lifestyle. You might almost say that wine was civilization, or a symptom of it.

Times have changed. Sales of wine and other alcoholic beverages have fallen dramatically. How many bottles of wine do you see on restaurant tables when you dine out? Not as many as a few years ago. And sometimes none at all. Glasses instead of bottles but, more likely, other beverages. We’ve been to a few places where the “mocktail” list is longer than the wine list.

Wine, the OG social beverage, isn’t the same any more. Is it passé, as Krugman might ask? Has it fallen from its place as a symbol of civilization?

Coffee Conundrum

Before I answer that question I want to provide a little context. Take a look at what’s happened to another OG beverage and see what you think.

Is coffee passé? Once upon a time coffee was cheap (for the most part) and ubiquitous. It was the default choice in many situations, sipped daintily or swilled by the mug. But coffee’s place in the world has changed. This is partly because of the Starbucks effect, where coffee has morphed into coffee-based beverages and then into a category of beverages that have little to do with coffee. The opportunity to share a pot of coffee doesn’t come up very often anymore. Everyone has their particular special order.

The next step in the coffee story seems to move even further from the OG roots. Dutch Bros. is one of the fastest-growing beverage shops. They offer a long list of espresso drinks like Starbucks, but they’ve taken the next step with customized drinks based on Rebel, their proprietary energy drink brand. In a way, Dutch Bros. has gone beyond coffee. But I am not sure it has left it behind (still making up my mind on this).

So what can we conclude about coffee? Passé or not? I’d go with Krugman’s conclusion about free trade. Coffee is still coffee, and its an integral part of existence, but its not the same. Coffee’s not the default any more. It’s one of the options. That’s a shame, but its a fact and companies like Starbucks and Dutch Bros. have embraced the change.

I guess I see wine in the same light. It’s not the same as it once was, but it is still important and the qualities that made it great will endure.

Krugman, Paul R. (1987). Is Free Trade Passé? Journal of Economic Perspectives, Vol. 1, No. 2, pp. 131-144. DOI: 10.1257/jep.1.2.131. [aeaweb.org], [aeaweb.org]

Leave a Reply