–
Boom Varietal: The Rise of Argentine Malbec. A film by Sky Pinnick (Kirk Ermisch, executive producer). “Southern Wine Group presents a Rage Productions documentary,” 2011.
We are just back from the BendFilm Festival in Bend, Oregon — an unlikely trip for a guy who sees about one new movie a year. The special occasion? The world premier of a documentary about the Malbec boom, Boom Varietal by filmmaker Sky Pinnick.
Simply Irresistible?
A film? About wine?. How could I resist?
Well, actually I might have been able to resist driving 6 hours from Tacoma to Bend for the premier since the track record for wine films is so mixed. Mondovino is a classic, of course, but it sure is long (or does it just seem that way while you’re watching it?) and it’s kinda annoying, too? So damn earnest! (“Le vin est mort” and all that.)
Then there’s Bottleshock, the film that’s loosely based on the famous “Judgment of Paris” tasting of French versus California wines in 1976. The film is a lot of fun (the opposite of Mondo?) but just as annoying since almost every single detail is distorted for dramatic effect or commercial purpose. The best way to watch Bottleshock is to forget that there really was a Paris tasting and enjoy the pure theater of the thing.
A Feast for the Senses
So which way would Boom Varietal go — earnest but annoying like Mondo or annoyingly commercial like Bottleshock?
Well, incredibly it is not annoying at all. In fact, it is completely enchanting. The first five minutes are a feast for the senses. The film captivated me, drawing me into the world of Malbec and the people and places associated with it.
The land and people of Argentina are the stars of this film, especially the winemakers. Executive producer Kirk Ermisch, CEO of Southern Wine Group, no doubt used his industry connections in Argentina to make the film possible, but he commendably resisted the temptation to make this a promotion piece for his business.
Typecasting? Dismal Scientist?
I went to Bend knowing that I had a bit part in the film. Sky and his wife and collaborator Shea Pinnick interviewed me me in my office last spring as they were trying to stitch together the video pieces to tell a coherent story. I’ve been writing about Argentinean Malbec for several years and obviously worrying about its future. My role, I thought, was to be the classic “dismal scientist” and wonder aloud if today’s silver lining isn’t really surrounded by a deep dark cloud. And that’s what it seemed to be when I viewed the film’s “teaser” (see above) a couple of weeks ago.
So imagine my surprise as I watched the film for the first time. I wasn’t dismal at all! Sky was able to capture my enthusiasm for Argentina and Malbec and my cautious optimism about its future in the world of wine. If Argentina’s Malbec industry falters (and that’s always a possibility in this uncertain world) I think it will be because of factors that are beyond the control of the winemakers — especially inflation and exchange rates.
I was also surprised to see myself on the screen so frequently. I think this is because Boom Varietal tells the story of the land, the people and the markets. A wine economics story! No wonder I had such a good time at the premier.
Beyond Malbec Boom?
I enjoyed this film and even learned a few things from it, but I had to keep reminding myself that this is a film about Malbec, not Argentinean wine more generally. Although the focus on Malbec is understandable and even appropriate for a U.S. audience (Malbec represents abut 2/3 of Argentina’s wine exports to the U.S.), one thing I learned from our trip to Mendoza earlier this year is that Argentina is Malbec, but not just Malbec.
If Malbec boom becomes Malbec bust (and I’m not predicting it will), then Argentina will be glad that it produces many other fine wines, both red and white. Search for Argentina among the Decanter World Wine Awards results and you will see what I mean. Maybe what lies beyond Malbec boom is not Malbec bust but a growing appreciate of Argentinean wine more generally.
But whatever happens I think Argentina will be thankful that Malbec vaulted them onto the world stage in the first place. An incredible story! Thanks to the makers of Boom Varietal for telling it so well.
>>><<<
Thanks to Sky and Shea Pinnick and to Kirk Ermisch for their hospitality while we were in Bend and for inviting me to participate in this project in the first place. I wish them every success with their project.
Nice article about Malbec and the film.
Too bad you kept misspelling Kirk Ermisch’s name as Emerish.
Yikes! How did I do that? Apologies to Kirk and thanks for catching the typo.
Congratulations Mike. You come across pretty well in the trailer…
An interesting movie.
We are excited to see the movie, and especially excited to see you on our big screen 🙂
Mike, either you saw a different version of Mondovino to the European release, or you’re even more easily annoyed than I am (which takes some doing). I saw a film that cared about its topic, yes, but certainly didn’t come over as excessively earnest, just concerned for the future of non-Parkerised wines. And that’s my opinion based on multiple viewings.
I don’t feel I’ve learned a lot about “Boom Varietal: The Rise of Argentine Malbec” from your review, however, just quite a bit about your appearance in it! What’s the film’s structure / bias? What’s its focus – origin, production, sales, consumption? I’m sure I’d like to see it anyway (as you say, it’s about wine, what’s to resist?), but a deeper insight into your take on the content would be much appreciated.
Thanks for this, EBGB. Maybe movie reviews aren’t my comparative advantage! With respect to Mondo, I respect the film and show it to my university class each semester, but I still find parts of it annoying. I actually think that might have been Nossiter’s intent — to try to provoke his audience in every possible way including by annoying them. According to his book, he had hundreds of hours of video to use in editing Mondo, so every element of the final assemblage was thoroughly calculated. Thanks for your comment.